Audit Objections

Classification and Grouping of Audit Objections

Circular Memo
No. 16808/W/WHOMP/98-9
Dated
24-07-2003
Source
Directorate of State Audit, Andhra Pradesh
View Source PDF

Important instructions from the Circular

  • Various types of audit objections are classified into 19 categories with distinct Code Numbers.
  • The Code Number of the relevant category should be indicated in the Audit Report.
  • Audit objections should be reported under the caption “Audit Objections” from the 2nd paragraph onwards.
  • The Code Number should be shown on the right side of the heading of the Audit Objection in brackets.
  • Objections belonging to the same category should be grouped under the same audit paragraph using sub-para numbers.
  • Separate paragraph numbers should NOT be given to objections falling under the same category.
  • Categories where there are no objections need not be shown as “Nil”.
  • Only categories in which objections are actually noticed need to be reported.
  • The revised classification applies to audits conducted from 2003-04 onwards relating to the year 2002-03.
  • Serial Nos. 20 and 21 are informative headings and are not Audit Objections.
  • For Gram Panchayats, the categorisation is to be followed in all three parts of the Audit Report.
  • Classifications for Universities, Temples and other Audit Parties were to be communicated separately; these 19 categories are not represented here as a universal classification for Universities.

19 classified categories

Category dashboard

Item 20Code 20

Receipts & Charges

Informative — not an audit objection

Item 21Code 21

Employees’ Particulars

Informative — not an audit objection

Item 22Code 26

Demand Drafts/Cheques/Bankers Cheques etc. received but not realised within time

Source numbering preserved

19 of 19 categories shown

Source details

Detailed category view

Category 1Code No. 1Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Difference between consolidated closing balance of Annual Account and closing balance of Cash Books.
  2. 2.Difference between the Cash Book balances and Treasury Pass Book not explained by preparing the Reconciliation Statement.
  3. 3.Monthly abstracts not recorded in the S.T. Pass Book and Certificate of balance not done by the Treasury Authorities – resulting in difference between the Cash Book balance and Pass Book balance.
  4. 4.Difference between the figures shown in the Annual Account with those in the Subsidiary Registers.
  5. 5.Difference between the amounts recorded in the Cash Book and amounts posted in the Arrear/Current Demand Registers in case of Municipalities and Gram Panchayats.
  6. 6.Lack of follow up action on the discrepancies pointed out in the earlier Audit Reports.
  7. 7.Errors in the Treasury Pass Book entries.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 2Code No. 2Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Expenditure incurred in excess of the actual receipt of the grant in anticipation of receipt of further grant.
  2. 2.Expenditure not confined to the extent of grant received.
  3. 3.Expenditure incurred in anticipation of sanction of grant inspite of non receipt of any amount.
  4. 4.Excess expenditure over and above the budget provision.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 3Code No. 3Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Grants sanctioned for a specific purpose spent for another purpose.
  2. 2.Incurring of expenditure for implementation of a particular scheme for which grant is yet to be released.
  3. 3.Temporary diversion of deposits like salary deductions/recoveries, i.e., GPF, Insurance premium, Profession Tax etc. for the general purposes of the institutions without remitting them to the relevant Heads of account.
  4. 4.Inter-transfer of funds from General Funds to Education Funds and vice versa.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 4Code No. 4Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Non-drawal of grants sanctioned and consequent non-utilisation.
  2. 2.Grants drawn but not fully utilised before the lapsable date.
  3. 3.Unspent balances of grants at the close of the permitted period of utilisation not refunded to State funds.
  4. 4.Inaction to seek extension of time to utilise the balances left out of grants already drawn after expiry of the utilisation period permitted.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 5Code No. 5Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Utilisation of Teaching Grant for payment of wages/salaries to sweepers working in schools and towards contingent expenditure like purchase of stationery in schools etc.
  2. 2.Utilisation of grants meant for repair works like R.R.M. and Special R.R.M. grants on original works.
  3. 3.Utilisation of grants meant for creation of assets on non-durable assets like formation of earthen roads.
  4. 4.Utilisation of institutions funds/grants received on expenditure of Government offices, including utilisation of Engineering Funds towards contingent expenditure of offices of Superintendent Engineer and expenditure on vehicles of Inspecting Officers for P.O.L. and repairs.
  5. 5.Utilisation of a particular grant on expenditure not connected with the purpose of the grant.
  6. 6.Utilisation of the funds of the institution for purposes/objects other than the permitted ones under the relevant Act/Rules.
  7. 7.Indiscriminate sanction of contingent advances and non-watching of adjustment of such advances and booking of such advances as expenditure under the grant.
  8. 8.Incurring of expenditure on items specifically prohibited by Government.
  9. 9.Incurring of expenditure without sanction by the competent authority.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 6Code No. 6Zilla Parishads, Mandal Parishads and Municipalities
  1. 1.Non-utilisation of earmarked funds fully towards S.C., S.T. and Women Development and Child Welfare activities.
  2. 2.Non-implementation of Government instructions issued in G.O.Ms.No.704 of P.R.&R.D. Department dated 05-11-1994, G.O.Ms.No.34 of Women Development & Child Welfare Department dated 29-05-1998 and G.O.Rt.Nos.450 & 451 of Panchayat Raj and Rural Development Department dated 09-04-2001 in earmarking funds of Zilla Parishads and Mandal Parishads, including non-remittance of 1/3rd earmarked amounts towards S.C., S.T. and Women Development and Child Welfare activities to the respective Corporations at the beginning of the year and also the unspent balances to these Corporations at the close of the year.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 7Code No. 7Zilla Parishads, Mandal Parishads, Gram Panchayats and Municipalities

Includes cases of office management resulting in short realisation of dues.

  1. 1.Non-collection of projected demand in respect of various taxes, fees, cess, leases and rents etc.; cent percent or percentage of collections falling short of previous years' percentage of collection.
  2. 2.Revenue by way of rent/lease amounts of residential staff quarters, guest houses, commercial complexes and usufruct of gardens/trees not realised and remitted to institution funds.
  3. 3.Non-initiation of legal action for realisation of revenue like issue of Notice of Distraint and filing of lawsuits against defaulters in payment of taxes, fees and lease amounts.
  4. 4.Hire charges of plant and tools and heavy machinery not realised from contractors.

Agricultural Market Committees

  1. 1.Non-collection of market fees levied under Section 12 of the Act.
  2. 2.Non-collection of licence fees in respect of purchasers and sellers of notified commodities.
  3. 3.Non-collection of licence fees from Commission Agents, Weighmen etc.
  4. 4.Miscellaneous receipts like sale proceeds of grass and cattle draping in the Market Yard not collected properly.
  5. 5.Non-collection of lease amounts of shops/godowns etc.

Zilla Grandhalaya Samsthas

  1. 1.Non-collection of Library Cess from Municipalities and Gram Panchayats.
  2. 2.Non-recovery of cost of Library Books lost/unreturned by borrowers.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 8Code No. 8Common to all Institutions
  1. •Personal Advances like Festival, Educational, Marriage, House Building and Conveyance advances paid to individuals not recovered.
  2. 2.Contingent advances paid for specific purposes like purchase of materials, goods and services not adjusted soon after the purpose is over.
  3. 3.Advances paid to Contractors as special cases not recovered and adjusted in Work Bills.
  4. 4.Non-refund of unspent balances out of advances paid.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 9Code No. 9Common to all Institutions

A. Procedural Lapses

  1. 1.Issue of work orders without administrative and technical sanctions.
  2. 2.Billing of work executed without measurements/check measurements and such payments.
  3. 3.Payment of final work bills without scrutiny by the Accounts Officer, Zilla Parishad.
  4. 4.Refund of deposits without verification of the original credit in the Register of Deposits.
  5. 5.Payment of advances without noting in the Register of Advances Recoverable.
  6. 6.Non-recording of entries in Service Books of employees and non-attestation of entries by the competent authority.
  7. 7.Irregularities in assessment of taxes, fees etc. and their collection.

B. Failure to Discharge Certain Obligations under Rules

Zilla Parishads, Mandal Parishads and Gram Panchayats

  1. 1.Lack of monitoring mechanism in implementation of various schemes entrusted to the institution.
  2. 2.Failure to take timely action to safeguard assets of the institution and put them to use.
  3. 3.Failure to take timely action to lease out assets to earn income.
  4. 4.Failure to respond on time to lawsuits filed by employees/outsiders against the institution to safeguard its interest.
  5. 5.Failure to discharge obligatory and discretionary functions under relevant Acts/Rules.

B. Failure to Discharge Certain Obligations — Municipalities

  1. 1.Failure to provide civic amenities like roads, sanitary facilities, street lighting and public health etc. to inhabitants.
  2. 2.Lack of timely action to control epidemics and contagious diseases.
  3. 3.Inaction in case of lawsuits against Municipalities.
  4. 4.Non-payment of Library Cess to Zilla Grandhalaya Samasthas.

B. Failure to Discharge Certain Obligations — Agricultural Market Committees

  1. 1.Non-payment of contribution to the Central Market Fund.
  2. 2.Non-payment of contributions at prescribed rates to the Pension-cum-Gratuity Fund of Market Committee Employees.
  3. 3.Inaction to check leakages in collection of Market Fees.
  4. 4.Irregularities in assessing Market Fees and their collection.
  5. 5.Non-payment of instalments of loans obtained on time.
  6. 6.Inaction to defend the interests of Market Committees where lawsuits were filed against them.
  7. 7.Non-payment of Audit Fees to Government Account.

B. Failure to Discharge Certain Obligations — Zilla Grandhalaya Samsthas

  1. 1.Lack of interest in maintaining library books in proper condition.
  2. 2.Non-purchase of reading material for the public.
  3. 3.Non-pursuance of action with Executive Authorities of Municipalities and Gram Panchayats for realisation of Library Cess.
  4. 4.Non-payment of Audit Fees to Government Account.

C. Purchases – Non-observance of Rules

  1. 1.Non-invitation of tenders/quotations wherever required for purchase of materials and services.
  2. 2.Resorting to purchases without assessing actual requirement and utility of materials.
  3. 3.Purchases from other than Government-approved organisations like APCO, APVC, SSI units and approved rate-contract sources.
  4. 4.Purchase of materials from firms situated outside the State when manufactured and available in the State.
  5. 5.Purchases in heavy quantities over and above actual requirement.
  6. 6.Purchases without realising beneficiaries' contributions.
  7. 7.Non-following of rules prescribed in Articles 122 to 129 of AP Financial Code in purchase of stores.
  8. 8.Payments for supplies ordered without receiving material/without verification of quantity/quality indented for supply.

D. Cases of Promotions/Appointments made Contrary to Rules

  1. 1.Appointments made without following Service Rules relating to qualifications, age, rule of reservation and ignoring the agency of recruitment and orders of Government.
  2. 2.Promotions ordered without observing conditions prescribed in respective Service Rules and without following the prescribed procedure.
  3. 3.Appointments to Automatic Advancement scales of ineligible employees.
  4. 4.Appointments contrary to provisions of Act 2 of 1994.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 10Code No. 10Common to all Institutions
Sub CodeDeduction / Recovery
101Income Tax – not remitted/partly remitted
102Sales Tax – not remitted/partly remitted
103Seigniorage Fee – not remitted/partly remitted
104GIS – not remitted/partly remitted
105APGLI – not remitted/partly remitted
106GPF – not remitted/partly remitted
107Employees Welfare Fund – not remitted/partly remitted
108Other recoveries such as Marriage Advance/HBA – not remitted/partly remitted
109Income Tax – not deducted
110Sales Tax – not deducted
111Seigniorage Fee – not deducted
112GIS – not deducted
113APGLI – not deducted
114GPF – not deducted
115Employees Welfare Fund – not deducted
116Other recoveries such as Marriage Advance/HBA – not deducted
117Library Cess collected but not remitted to Zilla Grandhalaya Samasthas
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 11Code No. 11Common to all Institutions
  1. •Vouchers not produced.
  2. 2.Files not produced.
  3. 3.Service Books not produced.
  4. 4.Stock Registers not produced.
  5. 5.Log Books not produced.
  6. 6.Registers not produced, including all Subsidiary Registers, Register of Money Value Forms, Register of M-Books etc.
  7. 7.Used MR Books not produced.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 12Code No. 12Common to all Institutions
  1. •Amounts collected but not brought to account.
  2. 2.Amounts collected not fully brought to account.
  3. 3.Amounts drawn on self-cheques not entered in the Petty Cash Book.
  4. 4.Undisbursed amount neither refunded nor physically available.
  5. 5.Drawal in excess of the voucher amount and non-accounting of the excess.
  6. 6.Drawal without proper voucher or without voucher.
  7. 7.Tampering of amounts noted in remittance challans.
  8. 8.Amounts shown in Cash Book as Treasury remittances using fictitious challans or without challans supporting the remittance.
  9. 9.Drawal more than once against a particular claim/charge not supported by disbursement particulars.
  10. 10.Self-cheque drawals for deductions/recoveries such as GPF, APGLI, GIS, HBA and Marriage Advance without remittance/disbursement and without recording the drawal in the Petty Cash Book.
  11. 11.Self-cheque drawal in excess of actual amount due to wrong totaling of different vouchers, without showing excess as Petty Cash Book balance.
  12. 12.Self-cheque drawal in excess of actual voucher amount by arriving at an incorrect amount and not accounting for the excess.
  13. 13.Non-accounting for cheques, demand drafts and cash received.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 13Code No. 13Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Erroneous calculations in bills/vouchers resulting in excess payments, including errors in addition, subtraction and multiplication in work bills and pay bills.
  2. 2.Adoption of higher rates than agreement rates in work bills or purchase bills of stores.
  3. 3.Excess payments due to wrong fixation of pay.
  4. 4.Excess payments due to higher D.A./Mileage/Fares and claims for ineligible persons in T.A., T.T.A. and L.T.C. bills.
  5. 5.Non-recovery/deduction of I.T., C.T., seigniorage charges, previous payments, F.S.D. etc. from work bills/suppliers' bills.
  6. 6.Erroneous calculation of quantities of items of work executed in work bills.
  7. 7.Non-recovery of cost of material supplied departmentally to contractors of civil works.
  8. 8.Payment of vehicle hire charges in excess of rates fixed and period, if any, permitted by Government.
  9. 9.Omissions in arrear bills such as non-deduction/wrong deduction of amounts already drawn and omissions in working out the ‘to be drawn’ amount.
  10. 10.Non-deduction of previous payment made to contractors in final bills.
  11. 11.Fixation of pay on promotion of employees already enjoying Automatic Advancement Scheme under FR-22B instead of FR 22(a)(i).
  12. 12.Release of increment before completion of 12 months service from date of refixation/stepping up of pay.
  13. 13.Allowing Family Planning Incentive Increment to ineligible employees.
  14. 14.Irregularities in casting leave account and sanction of leave.
  15. 15.Irregularities in permitting encashment of leave while in service and after retirement.
  16. 16.Irregularities in drawing pension/dearness relief to pensioners.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 14Code No. 14Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Expenditure on works abandoned halfway.
  2. 2.Expenditure on sub-standard works.
  3. 3.Drilling bore wells without precautionary measures like groundwater survey, resulting in failure.
  4. 4.Expenditure on assets not put to use.
  5. 5.Loss due to damage of stores such as cladding of cement, leakage of bitumen and rusting of steel due to improper storage.
  6. 6.Expenditure on publication of booklets/souvenirs highlighting achievements and arranging welcome/greeting banners.
  7. 7.Purchase of stores/services without immediate requirement and in excess of requirement.
  8. 8.Payment of Honorarium to R.M.Ps in Mandal Parishad Ayurvedic Dispensaries without supplying medicines.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 15Code No. 15Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Cash balance not handed over at change of incumbents.
  2. 2.Closing balances not brought forward as opening balances.
  3. 3.Stores such as cement, steel pipes, electrical materials, furniture, stationery and P.O.L. not properly entered in relevant Stock Registers and Log Books.
  4. 4.Replaced vehicle parts and condemned unserviceable articles not recorded in concerned Stock Registers for disposal.
  5. 5.Non-return of unused stock to stores in departmental execution of works.
  6. 6.Wrong balancing of stock accounts resulting in shortages.
  7. 7.Disagreement between book balances and physical stocks of stores/material.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 16Code No. 16Common to all Institutions
  1. 1.Utilisation period of the grant expired during the current year, but Utilisation Certificates not furnished to the grant-sanctioning authority though the entire grant was utilised.
  2. 2.Grant amount not fully utilised before the lapsable date, unspent balance not refunded and Utilisation Certificate for the amount utilised not furnished to the grant-sanctioning authority.
  3. 3.Utilisation Certificates submitted to the grant-sanctioning authority without countersignature by Audit authorities.

Utilisation Certificates pending proforma

Sl. No.Name of the Grant/SchemeG.O./Proceedings No. & Date of the sanctioning AuthorityGrant AmountLapsable date of the GrantAmount utilisedUnspent balanceChallan No. in which unspent balance retainedRemarks
(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6)(7)(8)(9)
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 17Code No. 17Institutions with Surcharge Certificates issued and recovery pending

Information regarding Surcharge Certificates issued but recovery pending should be mentioned under this category.

Surcharge Certificates recovery-pending proforma

S. No.S.C. No. & DateName of the SurchargeeAmount
(1)(2)(3)(4)
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 18Code No. 18Audit objections not covered under Categories 1–17

Audit objections not covered under any of the preceding categories fall under this category.

  1. 1.Losses and thefts occurred.
  2. 2.Non-submission of Annual Accounts to Audit within the time fixed under relevant Acts/Rules.
  3. 3.Non-maintenance of Registers.
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Category 19Code No. 19Common to all Institutions

Objections being raised for the year 2002-03 (i.e., audits being done from 01-04-2003 for the year 2002-03) may only be noted under ‘19. Status of Objections’.

Status of Objections proforma

S. No.YearObjections Code Nos.Total No. of ObjectionsTotal Amount
(1)(2)(3)(4)(5)
Related G.O.s / Circulars / Manuals: No related documents have been linked. Future documents can be added separately without altering this classification.

Source-only matching

Find the Relevant Audit Objection Category

Enter a short audit observation. Matches are limited to classifications and illustrations in this Circular Memo.

Audit Report format example

2. Miss-Utilisation of Grant(s)/Funds (5)

2
Serial number of the Audit Para.
5
Code Number of the Audit Objection Category.

4. Excess Payments (13) – Rs. 9,800/-

  1. (1) Excess payment of T.A. – Needs recovery – Rs.520/-
  2. (2) Excess payment consequent on adoption of higher rate than agreed rate – Needs recovery – Rs.1,230/-
  3. (3) Excess payment of Pay and Allowances due to wrong fixation of pay – Rs.8,050/-

No separate para numbers should be given to audit objections falling under the same Category.

Informative headings

Not Audit Objections

20Code No. 20Not an Audit Objection

Receipts & Charges

Under this Fund-wise totals of Receipts and Charges are to be furnished.

21Code No. 21Not an Audit Objection

Employees’ Particulars

Particulars of employees working in the institution as on the date of audit have to be furnished in the prescribed proforma.

S. No.DesignationNo. of Employees
(1)(2)(3)
22Code No. 26

Demand Drafts/Cheques/Bankers Cheques etc. received but not realised within time

The source document itself shows this as Serial No. 22 with Code No. 26.

Source numbering: Serial No. 22 / Code No. 26 is reproduced exactly as shown in the Circular.

Subsequent Instructions / Updates

No subsequent Audit-related Government Orders, Circulars or Manuals have been linked. Future source documents will appear here separately and will not overwrite the 2003 classification.

Source

Directorate of State Audit, Andhra Pradesh

Circular Memo No. 16808/W/WHOMP/98-9 · Dated 24-07-2003

This page reproduces the classification and illustrations contained in the above Circular Memo for reference and knowledge purposes. Users should verify the latest applicable Government Orders, Rules, Circulars and subsequent instructions before using any classification for current audit work.